SEO Consultant or AI Search Specialist: Which Does a Small Business Need?
Most small businesses need both kinds of work, but not two different people. Getting found in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity rests on the same foundations as getting found in Google: a clear website, pages that answer real questions, and other trusted sites mentioning you. Fix those first. The AI specific part sits on top.
The labels are newer than the work. Here is what each one means and what to look for.
What an SEO consultant does
Traditional search engine optimisation helps your pages rank in Google and Bing. That means fixing technical problems so pages can be read and indexed, writing pages that match what people search for, sorting your Google Business Profile, and earning links and mentions from other sites.
For a local business, the Google Business Profile and real reviews often matter more than anything on the website. I covered the basics in why your small business is invisible on Google.
What an AI search specialist does
AI assistants answer questions directly and name a handful of businesses. To be one of those names, your business needs to be easy for the AI to understand and easy for it to trust.
That work includes clear facts about who you are, what you do, where and for how much, written plainly on your site. It includes structured data, the behind the scenes labels that tell machines what a page is about. It includes pages that answer the exact questions buyers ask. And it includes being mentioned on other sites the AI reads: directories, reviews, local press and lists.
Bing matters more than people expect here, because several AI tools lean on its index. How to get your business found in ChatGPT and AI search goes into the detail.
Where the two overlap
Almost everywhere. A page that clearly answers a question helps both. Structured data helps both. Real reviews help both. Mentions on trusted sites help both. Fast, readable pages help both.
The difference is mostly in what gets measured. SEO tracks rankings and clicks. AI search tracks whether your business gets named when someone asks an assistant a buying question.
What to pay for first
If your site has technical problems, fix those first. Nothing else works if pages cannot be read.
Then make sure your basic facts are clear and consistent everywhere: name, services, area, prices if you publish them. Then build pages that answer your customers' real questions, one question per page where it makes sense. Then work on reviews and mentions.
That order works for Google and for AI. If someone sells you AI search without checking the basics, they are selling the top floor of a house with no foundations.
Red flags
Guaranteed rankings or guaranteed AI mentions. Nobody controls either. Link packages, where hundreds of links appear from sites nobody reads. They can get a site penalised. Monthly fees with no list of what was done. And reports full of numbers that never mention enquiries.
How I approach it
I track visibility in Google, Bing and the main AI assistants for my own sites and for clients, because one tells you little without the others. The work is the same honest work for both: fix the basics, answer the real questions, earn real mentions. If you want the wider picture of where AI fits in a small business, start with how a small business can use AI.
Quick answers
What is the difference between SEO and AI search optimisation?
SEO aims to rank your pages in Google and Bing. AI search optimisation aims to get your business named in answers from tools like ChatGPT and Gemini. Most of the groundwork is the same.
Do I need a separate AI search specialist?
Usually not. The same person can do both if they understand how AI assistants pick sources. Check they track AI mentions as well as rankings.
Does Bing matter for AI search?
Yes. Several AI assistants draw on Bing's index, so a site that is missing or weak in Bing can be missing from AI answers too.
Can anyone guarantee I will appear in ChatGPT?
No. AI answers vary and nobody controls them. Be wary of anyone who promises it.
Find out where you stand
If you want to know whether Google and the AI assistants can find you, book a free 20 minute call. Prices are on work with me, and more on the AI consultant page.
The 5 Step AI Roadmap for Small Businesses
The order I actually work in when somebody asks me to help, written so you can do it yourself if you would rather. Five steps, no jargon, including the step where the honest answer is that you do not need me.
I read every answer myself, and it only goes to me. Unsubscribe whenever.